FBI Surrounds Occupiers at the Malheur National Wildlife Refuge
This timeline is for informational purposes. Start to finish is listed bottom to top, as it progressed.
Gav’s Thursday LIVE Liberty Update.
Oregon Stream – Thursday Morning
At approximately 4:30 p.m. (Pacific) on Wednesday, February 10, 2016, one of the occupiers rode an ATV outside the barricades established by the militia at the Malheur National Wildlife Refuge. FBI agents attempted to approach the driver, and he returned to the encampment at the refuge at a high rate of speed.
At this time, the FBI has moved to contain the remaining occupiers by placing agents at barricades both immediately ahead of and behind the area where the occupiers are camping. Negotiations between the occupiers and the FBI continue. No shots have been fired.
“It has never been the FBI’s desire to engage these armed occupiers in any way other than through dialogue, and to that end, the FBI has negotiated with patience and restraint in an effort to resolve the situation peacefully. However, we reached a point where it became necessary to take action in a way that best ensured the safety of those on the refuge, the law enforcement officers who are on scene, and the people of Harney County who live and work in this area,” said Greg Bretzing, Special Agent in Charge of the FBI in Oregon.
Wednesday marks day 40 of the occupation of the refuge.
Further updates will be released as appropriate.
Currently Members inside the Refuge:
Four members left inside the Malheur National Wildlife Refuge are:
David Fry, 27, of Blanchester, Ohio; husband and wife Sean, 48, and Sandy Anderson, 47, both of Riggins, Idaho; and Jeff Banta, 46, of Elko, Nevada.
Our Prayer are with all of them, pray for their safe release.
Interesting after the YouTube Broadcast Youtube cut it to 1hr 59 min and 59 seconds not the full 4 hrs 44 minutes and 44 seconds. Also currently download is not available. Why? Update: The video has been restored to original time now.
Current Update from MSM Report:
Oregon state troopers and FBI agents pictured in Burns, Oregon, in January: four armed occupants remain inside the Malheur national wildlife refuge. Photograph: Jim Urquhart/Reuters
We’re wrapping up our live coverage for now, but will have all the latest developments ahead of the expected surrender of the remaining occupiers at 8am PST Thursday – you’ll be able to find that here.
In the meantime, here’s our latest news round-up. Thanks for reading.
Four remaining occupiers of the Malheur wildlife refuge in Burns, Oregon, say they will turn themselves in to the FBI at 8am PST Thursday.
But doubts have been raised over the apparent agreement after Cliven Bundy – a figurehead for the militia and the father of two former Oregon occupiers now in jail – was himself arrested on the way to the scene of the refuge.
The reported surrender deal came after FBI agents surrounded the refuge on Wednesday night, 40 days after armed militia members took control of the property.
Sean Anderson, one of the four, insisted the decision was not a surrender:
We are not surrendering, we’re turning ourselves in …
It goes against everything we believe in but we’re going to do it.
But there has been no confirmation from the FBI of the terms of the reported agreement.
The Narrows roadblock near Burns, where FBI agents have surrounded the remaining four occupiers at the Malheur national wildlife refuge. Photograph: Thomas Boyd/AP
Speaking earlier in the evening, Greg Bretzing, special agent in charge of the FBI in Oregon, said:
It has never been the FBI’s desire to engage these armed occupiers in any way other than through dialogue, and to that end, the FBIhas negotiated with patience and restraint in an effort to resolve the situation peacefully.
However, we reached a point where it became necessary to take action.
The four – along with a number of fellow militia members already arrested – face federal felony charges of conspiracy to impede officers from discharging official duties through the use of force, intimidation or threats.
If convicted, the four – Anderson and his wife Sandy Anderson, Jeff Banta and David Fry – could face six-year prison sentences.
Nevada assemblywoman Michele Fiore – who, in a sometimes surreal live stream conversation with the occupiers, acted as an unofficial mediator – says she will also be at the checkpoint, along with Christian evangelist Rev Franklin Graham.
It’s understood that Cliven Bundy has been charged in relation to a separate standoff, in Nevada, which took place in 2014.
That began when the federal Bureau of Land Management (BLM) wanted to seize cows belonging to Cliven Bundy – a Nevada rancher and the father of Ammon and Ryan Bundy, key figures in the Oregon standoff – over $1.2m (£840,000) in unpaid fees for grazing on federal land over two decades.
Bundy rejected the agency’s authority, triggering the faceoff. He continued to graze his cattle on federal land and has said he would not pay the bill.
Sam Levin has been talking to Mike Arnold, Ammon Bundy’s attorney who is currently driving with assemblywoman Fiore to the refuge.
Arnold confirmed by phone that Cliven Bundy has been arrested, which he said he learned from the FBI.
He said he worried it could derail the plan for a resolution at the refuge on Thursday morning:
“It’s unfortunate timing considering all the progress that we made this evening, but I hope that the folks at the refuge find some positive observations out of it.
“Cliven was arrested safely and without incident, without harm.
“So we’re hoping tomorrow everything turns out the same and everybody can be in that courtroom together arguing their position.”
In a brief phone chat with the Guardian’s Sam Levin just after 11pm PST, Cliven Bundy’s wife Carol confirmed that he had flown in, but said she didn’t know if he had been detained.
Two Bundy sons – Ammon and Ryan – are already being held in Multnomah county jail in connection with the Malheur refuge standoff.
I’m now seeing reports that Cliven Bundy – the father of Oregon militia leader Ammon Bundy, and who earlier told the Guardian he was on the way to the site of the standoff – has been detained and is being held in Multnomah county jail.
Four remaining occupiers of the Malheur wildlife refuge in Burns, Oregon, say they will turn themselves in to the FBI at 8am PST Thursday.
The pledge came after FBI agents surrounded the refuge on Wednesday night, 40 days after armed militia members took control of the property.
Sean Anderson, one of the four, insisted the decision was not a surrender:
We are not surrendering, we’re turning ourselves in …
It goes against everything we believe in but we’re going to do it.
But there has been no confirmation from the FBI of the terms of the reported agreement.
Speaking earlier in the evening, Greg Bretzing, special agent in charge of the FBI in Oregon, said:
It has never been the FBI’s desire to engage these armed occupiers in any way other than through dialogue, and to that end, the FBI has negotiated with patience and restraint in an effort to resolve the situation peacefully.
However, we reached a point where it became necessary to take action.
The four – along with a number of fellow militia members already arrested – face federal felony charges of conspiracy to impede officers from discharging official duties through the use of force, intimidation or threats.
If convicted, the four – Anderson and his wife Sandy Anderson, Jeff Banta and David Fry – could face six-year prison sentences.
Nevada assemblywoman Michele Fiore – who, in a sometimes surreal live stream conversation with the occupiers, acted as an unofficial mediator – says she will also be at the checkpoint, along with Christian evangelist Rev Franklin Graham.
Michele Fiore was a Republican state legislator – barely known outside Nevada – before she was thrust into the heart of the Oregon militia standoff on Wednesday in the most dramatic and bizarre of circumstances.
Shortly after the FBI closed in on the armed militia, sparking panic among the four remaining occupiers at the Malheur national wildlife refuge, Fiore was on the line acting as a mediator with law enforcement officials.
Michelle Fiore, pictured in 2013, emerged as a mediator-cum-cheerleader for the remaining occupiers. Photograph: Cathleen Allison/AP
Her dramatic conversations with the militia, whom she pleaded to hold back from confronting the FBI, were broadcast, in real time, on YouTube, in a live-stream that at one stage had upwards of 60,000 listeners.
As the four occupiers decided to turn in for the night – ahead of their scheduled meeting on Thursday morning in which the turning-in will be to the FBI – live stream host Gavin Seim played them a song by Victoria Sharp.
Sam Levin reports:
Sharp, an 18-year-old from Kansas, became a key figure in the standoff after she spoke out about LaVoy Finicum’s shooting.
Sharp was in the car with Finicum when law enforcement officials stopped them on a remote highway. She later told reporters that Finicum had his hands up when he was fatally shot – a claim the FBI has refuted.
The New York Times profiled the Sharp Family Band, which came to Oregon to perform for protesters. The family gospel band was also present at Cliven Bundy’s 2014 standoff with the federal government in Nevada. To Oregon, Victoria’s mother, Odalis Sharp, brought eight of her kids, aged five to 18.
When the family was waiting to hear if Victoria had survived the shooting with police, the family sang gospel songs inside a crowded senior center – sobbing all the way through, according to the Times.
The FBI has not commented publicly on the move to bring to an end the 40-day standoff since an early press release confirmed agents had circled the refuge.
Greg Bretzing, special agent in charge of the FBI in Oregon, said then:
It has never been the FBI’s desire to engage these armed occupiers in any way other than through dialogue, and to that end, the FBI has negotiated with patience and restraint in an effort to resolve the situation peacefully.
However, we reached a point where it became necessary to take action in a way that best ensured the safety of those on the refuge, the law enforcement officers who are on scene, and the people of Harney County who live and work in this area.
After another round of prayers, the four occupiers say they are going to try to get some sleep ahead of their scheduled meeting with the FBI at 8am PST Thursday – when they will turn themselves in.
Fiore confirms she will be on the scene on Thursday morning.
She says the first amendment and the free press are the reason the four are alive tonight.
Four remaining occupiers of the Malheur wildlife refuge in Burns, Oregon, say they will turn themselves in to the FBI at 8am PST Thursday.
The pledge came after FBI agents surrounded the refuge on Wednesday night, 40 days after armed militia members took control of the property.
Sean Anderson, one of the four, said the decision was not a surrender:
We are not surrendering, we’re turning ourselves in …
It goes against everything we believe in but we’re going to do it.
The four – along with a number of fellow militia members already arrested – face federal felony charges of conspiracy to impede officers from discharging official duties through the use of force, intimidation or threats.
If convicted, the four – Anderson and his wife Sandy Anderson, Jeff Banta and David Fry – could face six-year prison sentences.
Nevada assemblywoman Michele Fiore – who, in a sometimes surreal live stream conversation with the occupiers, has acted as an unofficial mediator – says she will be at the checkpoint, along with Christian evangelist Rev Franklin Graham.
Sean Anderson repeats that the occupiers intend to “turn ourselves in” on Thursday morning.
In the meantime, he says, they want to return to their camp and sleep for the night, before meeting the FBI (along with Fiore and Franklin Graham, potentially) at the checkpoint:
I just hope that they keep their word. We’ll keep our word. And we’ll clear this up in the morning.
Anderson tells Fiore:
We are not surrendering, we’re turning ourselves in …
It goes against everything we believe in but we’re going to do it.
We’re going to walk one after another, with the flag, and we’re going to turn ourselves in.
This map shows the layout of the Malheur wildlife refuge. The four occupiers say they are no longer inside the buildings but are camping in the grounds.
What are the charges the four occupiers are facing? Sam Levin explains:
The four holdouts – along with 12 others associated with the standoff who have already been taken into custody – are all facing federal felony charges of conspiracy to impede officers from discharging official duties through the use of force, intimidation or threats.
The charge of impeding government officials is a broad allegation that experts say covers many of the illegal actions that have occurred at the federally protected wildlife sanctuary.
The basic contention of federal prosecutors is that protesters’ armed occupation blocked government workers from executing their duties at the refuge.
Prosecutors largely targeted high-profile leaders and militia members and then added the four holdouts to the case in a recent grand jury indictment.
Gavin Seim, hosting the broadcast, tells Sandy Anderson that Ammon Bundy and other arrested militia members have been taken out of solitary confinement.
Anderson doesn’t seem impressed – she says the FBI wants to end the occupation at the refuge so they can add extra charges to those already held, and the four who remain. She says they will never see the light of day again.
Michele Fiore is a Republican Nevada state assemblywoman. Now in her second term, the Brooklyn native is perhaps best known for her adamant support of gun rights and Cliven Bundy’s 2014 standoff with the federal government.
On Monday, Fiore announced that she would travel to Oregon to support Ammon Bundy and the other Malheur occupiers currently under indictment. Fiore had planned to hold a press conference at the law offices of Arnold law firm on Thursday morning where a statement from Ammon Bundy would be read.
In 2014, Fiore spent time at Cliven Bundy’s Nevada ranch during the family’s standoff with the Bureau of Land Management. Fiore called the militia members who participated in the armed standoff “freedom fighters” and called on members of law enforcement agencies “not to obey your superiors when given a direct order to attack your fellow Americans fighting for the freedoms granted to us by our constitution”.
Fiore drew national attention again last December for her Christmas card, which featured her entire family, including a small child, holding firearms. “It’s up to Americans to protect America. We’re just your ordinary American family,” Fiore wrote in a Facebook post sharing the image.
The feed of the live phone call is at turns disturbing and downright surreal. There was just a moment of sheer panic when Sean Anderson announced he was going to light an outdoor heater.
“I am going to light a propane heater cos we are standing out here freezing cold,” he said.
“Don’t do that, don’t do that,” replied Congresswoman Fiore.
There appeared to be a frantic attempt to communicate with the FBI that the occupiers were on the cusp of lighting their heater, so they didn’t misunderstand what was happening.
Amid discussions about whether there were flammable materials in the area, and attempts to implore Anderson not to light the heater, he replied: “I am going to go ahead and light this so my wife can be warm. If they shoot them that’s on their fucking ass.”
The fourth occupier is Jeff Banta – here’s some background on him, courtesy of AP:
The 47-year-old has lived in Elko, Nevada, the last several years and worked in construction most of his life, his ex-wife said.
Banta graduated from Yerington high school in the rural town of Yerington, about 70 miles (113km) southeast of Reno, said Angela Ellington Banta, who still lives there.
His father, Willard Banta, 73, said all of his children grew up hunting and fishing at an early age.
“I had them out in the hills with me as soon as they were old enough to walk and out of diapers,” he said.
The elder Banta said he had talked to his son “once or twice” since the standoff began but declined to provide details.
“He just said, ‘I’m all right,”’ Willard Banta said. “I’m wondering if he is going to make it out. I’d like to see my son come home. I hope he does, but I have my doubts.”
Jeffrey Banta and his ex-wife have two children, the eldest a 23-year-old woman who is married and has a child, living in the Reno area.
Ellington Banta said she doesn’t really know what her ex-husband has been doing in recent years and doesn’t want to discuss the standoff because she has “two kids who have been really affected by all this”.
The four people still inside the refuge – David Fry, Jeff Banta, and husband-and-wife Sean and Sandy Anderson – were all named in a federal indictment last week.
They – along with Ammon Bundy and others tied to the armed standoff – face federal conspiracy charges over their alleged use of “force, intimidation, and threats” against government officials, according to the indictment.
A federal grand jury has accused Bundy and the other militia members of preventing US Fish and Wildlife Service officers from discharging their official duties at the Malheur national wildlife refuge since 2 January.
The four remaining occupiers have said they refuse to leave unless they have assurances they would not face charges.
Fiore – who appears to be acting as a curious mixture of negotiator and cheerleader – tells the occupiers that they are engaged in a battle to take America back.
She is being driven to the refuge now, in a journey expected to take around four hours.
Fiore says her cellphone signal might drop as they drive through mountains, but says the FBI will not act while the signal is down (we don’t have confirmation of that alleged agreement from the FBI).
“In order to stay alive, I have to submit and be a slave,” Sean Anderson shouts. He compares himself to Braveheart.
Associated Press has further background information on two of the occupiers, husband and wife Sean and Sandy Anderson:
The husband and wife moved from the town of Janesville, Wisconsin, within the last several years to Riggins, Idaho, where Sean, 47, opened a store for hunting, tactical and survival gear. Sandy, 48, worked at a gas station.
Idaho County, where they live, and Harney County, 290 miles away where the refuge is located, are similar in many ways. Both have large portions of land managed by federal agencies and populations chafing at restrictions put on that land.
Idaho county sheriff Doug Giddings said the Andersons are good residents, though he didn’t know as much about Sean as he did about Sandy.
“She’s a good person, she’s just upset with the government,” he told Oregon Public Broadcasting.
Sean Anderson is facing misdemeanor charges in Wisconsin for resisting an officer, possession of drug paraphernalia and possession of THC, the intoxicating chemical in marijuana.
He also has pleaded guilty to a series of misdemeanors in recent years: domestic abuse in December 2010, disorderly conduct in 2008, criminal trespass in a dwelling in 2002, and disorderly conduct in 1999.
A friend of the couple, Lindsey Dipo, told the Lewiston Tribune newspaper that the couple recorded their will on Dipo’s cellphone before departing for Oregon.
Cliven Bundy has confirmed in a phone interview with the Guardian just now that he is on his way to the refuge.
“I hope I save some lives, for one thing,” he said.
The elder Bundy said he decided to go to Harney County after he saw the FBI was closing in on the occupiers:
I guess if they wanted to murder somebody tonight, that’d be a good way to do it.
I don’t know whether I’ll be a negotiator or maybe a demander. I think we oughta take this country back and I think it’s time the feds get out of there.
Bundy said he has not heard from law enforcement:
I’m not really talking to the FBI. As far as I’m concerned, they have no jurisdiction or authority there.
Bundy declined to say if anyone else was with him or how long it would take him to get there.
Sean Anderson says he wants assurances that the four occupiers won’t face prosecution.
“They can drop charges, they do it all the time – for people who are way worse than we are,” he told Fiore.
The occupiers are also telling the assemblywoman that Franklin Graham, a reverend from the Billy Graham Evangelistic Association, is in discussions with them. The occupiers said the FBI may consider letting them walk out at 7am Thursday morning with Graham.
But Sean Anderson said he wasn’t confident they would get out alive: “How can we trust what they are saying?”
Sean Anderson, one of the occupiers, has just announced what he calls their “concession” – that the four of them will leave the refuge in daylight on Thursday if they are allowed to be accompanied by Congresswoman Fiore and Christian evangelist Franklin Graham.
He says the FBI must now offer its own concession in return.
According to a Facebook page associated with the militia, Cliven Bundy – father of Ammon Bundy and himself involved in an earlier standoff with officials – is on his way to the site of the siege.
However, the FBI has reportedly told the four occupiers that nobody will be able to enter the property.
The live broadcast just captured the moment the occupiers heard helicopters above the refuge.
“The black hawks are here and they’re going to kill us,” said one voice, which appeared to be David Fry, the most agitated of the occupiers.
He added moments later: “If they fire first, my weapon is in reach and I’m going to take them with me.”
Gavin Seim, the rightwing activist who is running the Youtube broadcast, led a group prayer for those inside, and assured them that leader Ammon Bundy, who in prison, has been taken out of solitary confinement.
Assemblywoman Michele Fiore – who is also on the line, acting as a mediator – is also encouraging the remaining occupiers to remain calm. “I need you to stay alive. The only way we’re going to be able to write your story and write your book is if you stay alive.”
The occupiers appear to have a separate line to the FBI, and are relaying that they’ve been told no one will be allowed on to the refuge until they leave.
“They want us to leave. They said the time for concessions has passed,” Sandy Anderson said.
The details are sketchy, and the audio in parts inaudible, but it appears that one proposal is for a local figure, possibly a reverend, to join the occupiers and lead them off the site.
Fry had previously communicated with militia spokesman LaVoy Finicum online, and Finicum had reportedly encouraged the young occupier to stay.
Fry’s family told the radio station that he has frequently had problems with authorities.
“He’s had his problems, some of which he’s brought on himself,” his grandfather, William Fry, told OPB.
“He gets pulled over for busted tail-lights, and instead of just rolling down his window and handing over his insurance, he screams at the officer: ‘What the [expletive] do you want?’ And right there, a regular thing turns into him in handcuffs.”
Fry also often writes about conspiracy theories online.
The occupation at Malheur started on 2 January in response to the conviction of two local ranchers on arson charges. Our explainer has more on the background to the 40-day standoff:
In the live stream audio, occupier David Fry can be heard shouting that they have broken no laws and demanding that FBI agents leave the refuge surrounds.
Fiore has suggested that the occupants tell FBI negotiators that they will walk out of the refuge together, if law enforcement officials allow Fiore to come to the refuge.
“There’s been one martyr too many,” Fiore tells them.
The assemblywoman says she is currently at the airport.
Assemblywoman Michele Fiore, a Nevada lawmaker who supported rancher Cliven Bundy in a 2014 standoff with the government, called the occupiers at around 6.15pm PST, saying she wanted to act as a negotiator between the FBI and the protesters.
In a call broadcast on YouTube, Fiore said to the occupiers:
We need a negotiator on the phone immediately.
I will come to the refuge … We cannot afford more bloodshed.
I’m willing to negotiate with the FBI for a peaceful resolution.
Fiore said she had arrived in Oregon and was willing to come to the occupation to help the two sides communicate in an effort to avoid violence.
Occupier Sandy Anderson shouted to the FBI in response:
You need to stand down. [Fiore] says you need to stand down. She’s coming here to settle this peacefully! Not your way!
Ammon Bundy, the leader of the militia group that seized the refuge on 2 January, told his attorneys last week that the four people maintaining the occupation should “go home to your families”.
The protest was “never meant to be an armed standoff”, he said, in a cellphone call to his attorneys, Mike Arnold and Lissa Casey, who taped the conversation and relayed it to the holdouts at the refuge 30 miles north-east of Burns.
Bundy is currently held in the Multnomah County jail in Portland on federal felony charges. He was arrested in a traffic stop that also resulted in the fatal shooting of activist Robert LaVoy Finicum.
The four holdouts at the Malheur national wildlife refuge are David Fry, Jeff Banta, and husband-and-wife Sean Anderson and Sandy Anderson.
The FBI surrounded the four remaining occupiers on Wednesday night, prompting a dramatic standoff that was live-streamed on YouTube.
According to an FBI statement, one of the occupiers drove outside of the police barricades on Wednesday afternoon, and agents attempted unsuccessfully to approach the individual.
On a live stream published by activist Gavin Seim, a woman identifying herself as Sandy Anderson shouted:
Please don’t let us die in vain tonight! If they shoot us and kill us, this is going to be a revolution!
Although reports from Burns, Oregon, are still unclear, what we do know is that the FBI is surrounding the Malheur wildlife refuge, where four armed militia members continue their 40-day occupation.
The FBI has released a statement confirming the escalation:
At approximately 4.30pm (Pacific) on Wednesday, February 10, 2016, one of the occupiers rode an ATV outside the barricades established by the militia at the Malheur National Wildlife Refuge. FBI agents attempted to approach the driver, and he returned to the encampment at the refuge at a high rate of speed.
At this time, the FBI has moved to contain the remaining occupiers by placing agents at barricades both immediately ahead of and behind the area where the occupiers are camping. Negotiations between the occupiers and the FBI continue. No shots have been fired.
Greg Bretzing, special agent in charge of the FBI in Oregon, said:
It has never been the FBI’s desire to engage these armed occupiers in any way other than through dialogue, and to that end, the FBI has negotiated with patience and restraint in an effort to resolve the situation peacefully. However, we reached a point where it became necessary to take action in a way that best ensured the safety of those on the refuge, the law enforcement officers who are on scene, and the people of Harney County who live and work in this area.
Our most up-to-date story is here and we will have more updates as this news continues to develop:
If you support the information in this article PLEASE SHARE on your Social Media. It only takes a second of your time to click the provided share buttons. You show your support through your sharing.
Thanks for visiting MaxResistance please like our Facebook and subscribe to our Twitter. If you would like to keep up to date on all our articles please hit the *FOLLOW button at the bottom right of this page and keep up with all our current articles. Thank you for your support, and please share our site and information.